A number of higher-end grocery stores, such as Whole Foods Market,
Publix and Harris Teeter, are trying to woo cost-conscious
consumers as they search for bargain prices or cut back on luxury
spending, The Tennessean reports.
All three stores said they are offering more discounts on basic
food items from milk to produce and touting store brands as cheaper
alternatives.
"I think the main message retailers are getting loud and clear is
value for money is more important to more shoppers than it was a
year ago," said Bill Bishop, chairman of Barrington, Ill.-based
food and retail consultant Willard Bishop. "They've got to figure
out how to deliver greater value for money."
Whole Foods may face the biggest challenge.
"It's kind of a sign of the times we have more consumers looking
for value than ever before," said Ron Paul, president of Technomic
Inc., a Chicago-based research firm. "The 'whole paycheck' image
gives them a poor price image and they are starting to fight
back."
Nashville Prices Stable
In June, the latest month with complete data, consumer food prices
increased 5 percent nationally compared with a year ago, according
to the U.S. Bureau of Labor Statistics.
But in the Nashville area, based on a supermarket survey by The
Tennessean last week, prices of a market basket of 16 basic items
remained flat compared with prices two months ago. Consumers would
have spent $39.71 for the grocery cart of goods in mid-June and
$39.22 for the same items last week, the survey found. Prices at
several area stores were checked and then averaged for each
item.
Some costs rose over the two months, though. The average price of
boneless chicken breast increased 12 cents a pound, a dozen eggs
were up a nickel, and cheddar cheese increased 32 cents a
pound.
"It's hard on people," said Jan Housman, 54, who clips coupons and
looks for deals on food.
In a recent survey by the Arlington, Va.-based Food Marketing
Institute, about
37 percent of shoppers said lower prices are the top reason they
pick one store over another -- a consumer-choice factor that rose
by 6 percentage points compared with a similar survey last
year.
Supermarkets are taking note. Lakeland, Fla.-based Publix offers
more "buy one, get one free" deals as well as coupons that let
consumers get a private-label item for a penny after purchasing a
certain amount of other merchandise.
Harris Teeter recently launched a "Budget Stretchers" program with
savings on bread and "buy two, get one free" incentives.
"The troubles with the economy are migrating up the income scale,"
said Stephanie Hoff, an analyst at Edward Jones in St. Louis.
"We're responding to the economy. We realize customers are trying
to cut back and save where they can," Publix spokeswoman Brenda
Reid said.
"Every day is a battle for everybody in the industry because prices
fluctuate so frequently. We have to stay abreast of what our
competitors are doing, what prices they are charging, and price our
products competitively," Reid added.
Whole Foods' Stock Falls
Whole Foods Market Inc., the largest U.S. natural-foods grocer, has
seen its stock fall nearly two-thirds in value since hitting a
52-week high above $53 a share many months ago. On Monday, the
stock closed at $19.73 a share on Nasdaq.
Sales prospects for the fourth quarter look iffy. Last week, the
grocer said fourth-quarter profits would be far less than stock
analysts had anticipated as the supermarket chain watches its sales
growth stall at many stores amid soaring utility and fuel costs,
and other pressures on consumers.
Whole Foods operates two stores in Nashville -- one it built new in
Green Hills and a Wild Oats outlet it took over and has renamed in
Cool Springs. It also has a store in Memphis that still carries the
Wild Oats name.
"You have to eat, but Whole Foods is an aspirational store, so
they're more hurt in this environment than traditional grocery
stores," said Edward Aaron, an analyst at RBC Capital Markets in
Denver. "Those perceptions are definitely hurting the
results."
Revenue in the three months ended July 6 rose 22 percent to $1.84
billion for Whole Foods, but sales growth at stores open at least a
year slowed to 2.6 percent from 6.7 percent the previous quarter.
Some analysts had estimated same-store sales growth would increase
about 6 percent.
"A 2.6 percent (result) is really worrisome," said Hoff, the Edward
Jones analyst. "The trend could last for a while. This number is
below some of the mainline grocery stores, which suggests a
(market) share shift."
Value Tours are New
Meanwhile, Whole Foods started its value tours this summer, calling
some of its employees "value gurus." They tell shoppers how to save
money by looking for store brands or buying in bulk more
frequently.
Some Whole Foods Market customers remain skeptical, though.
"I'm mortified by the expense here," said Bill Lane, 68, of Forest
Hills, who sampled some organic cookies at a Whole Foods last week.
"It's hard not to come and spend $100."
In-house value guru Bergmann, who said he spends about $400 a month
at Whole Foods for himself and his wife, counters that many of the
items priced higher in Whole Foods' aisles are specialty foods with
higher-quality ingredients.





